Less other train accidents on level crossing

The problem: a second train behind the first train at a level crossing. The solution: hide technology, hide the real situation and lie.



Legal solution

The first solution is giving trains priority and sue the tracks crosser in case of an accident. To have a strong case the law can be put on a sign near the tracks (see figure 1 at the right).

level crossing Figure 1. A legal message

Tram has priority.

Source: Tram station. Brussels Midi, Belgium, 2010.

Explain technology in static text

The second solution is to communicate technology that causes the danger, e.g. present the number of tracks (See Figure 2). It is not sure that from knowing the number of tracks, the tracks crosser will conclude that there might be another train coming on one of the other tracks. level crossing
Figure 2. Message describing the technical situation

Source: common practice in the US.
  It might be better to present the consequence of the technology used: another train might appear (see Figure 3). The main advantage of these static text solutions still is a legal one. In court the track company can blame the track crossers saying: Don’t blame us, we installed a sign. The main disadvantage of static text solutions is a psychological one. Static text is unconspicious and people do not read them. Especially track crossers that need them most: regular users. level crossing Figure 3. The danger in the message

WAIT, until the red light is switched off, another train might appear.

Source: common practice in the Netherlands.
To top.



Piece of art

Belgium Railways and Netherlands railways have a third solution for the problem. They asked artists to solve the problem (see figure 4 at the right). This piece of art might be interpreted as piece of art and not as a warning. This is called function fixedness: the obvious function is detected first and a second function is not detected. Functional fixedness is commonly used in riddles. level crossing
Figure 4. An artistic message

Do you want to stay alive? Just wait for a moment.

Source: The Netherlands, experimental sign ProRail. http://www.nicospilt.com/index2.html
To top.



Static graphic solutions

A fourth solution is using graphics. Graphics can be more conspicuous than text because a complex situation can be perceived in a glance (compare  Figure 3 and Figure 4).

Designing comprehensible graphics is difficult as Figure 5 shows. The arrows in  Figure 5 can be interpreted in the following ways.
  • Trains crossing here. The other train risk is not understood because simultaneousness of two trains is not obvious. Parker (2002) observed that most pedestrians interpreted a second train sign as a warning. 4% interpreted the sign as a warming for a second train.

  • Look left for the train on the first track you are crossing. The conclusion might be: No train from the left, I can cross.

  • The train on the first track you are crossing moves left. The conclusion might be: There is a train on the left (e.g. standing at a platform) but that will not cross the level crossing.

  • The confusion might increase because of inconsistency of driving side between road and train traffic. Road traffic in France and Belgium keeps right, trains keep left. In the UK it is the other way round. In addition, train traffic control might decide to switch driving side.
  • It is unlikely that hurried track crossers focusing on the first train and seeing this sign (figure 5) in the split second available will be capable of making the cognitive psychological analysis above, select the correct interpretation and finally will conclude: I don’t cross. level crossing
    Figure 5. A message with arrows

    Source: sign used in Austria.
    To top.



    Dynamic text solutions

    The solution discussed so far are static and as such inappropriate to attract attention. The only way to catch the attention of the inexperienced and experienced track crossers is the fifth solution using dynamics as in figure 6 and 7. The dynamics are used in other train situations only, on top of the one train only coming signs. In this way experienced track crossers will distinguish between one and two train situations. Figure 7 is to be preferred because it directs attention immediately to the text. level crossing
    Figure 6. Conspicuous light with text explaining the technical situation

    Source: UK.

    level crossing
    Figure 7. Conspicuous text explaining the technical situation

    Source: UK
    To top.



    A dynamic realistic solution

    The disadvantage of a text solution is that the text is not read, especially not by the focus group: track crossers having experience with that track. Parker (2002) investigated a sixth solution: a realistic dynamic presentation including moving trains, blinking arrows and left-right looking track crossers heads (see Figure 9). 27% of the track crossers interpreted the sign as a general always look left and right sign for one or more trains, 41% interpreted the sign as do not cross, a train is coming and 20% did not understand the sign at all. In a follow-up survey four percent directly related the sign to the presence of two trains.

    The design strategy is as in Figure 2: present technical reality and hope that the tracks crosser will understand the danger. level crossing Figure 9. Dynamic realistic graphics for the hidden train problem

  • train is coming from right, track crossers head is facing right

  • second train from left, head facing left

  • both trains on crossing

  • both trains left crossing


  • Source: Parker 2002
    To top.



    A dynamic psychological solution:

    lie

    The sign in figure 9 is most conspicuous (a large area lightening up)  when the track crosser physically can’t cross, i.e. when there is a train on the level crossing. The message should be most conspicuous when the tracks crosser decides to cross. This is the time period when there is no train on the level crossing yet, i.e. when the tracks crosser can cross but should not. In the seventh solution the sign should graph the crosser by the collar just before the moment he decides to cross. The best, of course would be some kind of subject too close to the tracks detection that switches on in the period the decision is made only. Next best is an estimate of that moment.

    The sign in figure 9 seems to be for a second train from the opposite direction only. In that case the tracks crosser can see both trains. The message to communicate is much more complex when the second train is hidden. A first crossing train can hide a second train from the opposite direction after crossing. A slow train on the first track to cross can, before crossing, hide a fast second train that will arrive at the crossing first. In those situations the solutions discussed so far, might encourage the track crosser to cross because they support the strategy: OK, another one is coming, I don’t see it yet (approaching from the other direction as usual or according to some signs), I still can make it. In practice the track crosser might cross the first visible train just in time but then is caught by the hidden train. Designing a sign saying: two visible opposite trains crossing simultaneously proved to be difficult. How to communicate the more complex situation of a hidden second train?

    Presenting the real situation is a dead end. Communication should not be an explanation of the technical situation nor a presentation of reality.
    The best solution is message saying somehow: This is a more complex and dangerous situation than usual. Just don’t cross. This graphic does not need to match reality but should be understood instantly.
    To top.





    References

    Heavisides, J.,Barrett, M. & Hesketh S. , (2009). Another train coming warnings at automatic level crossings Third International Conference on Rail Human Factors, 3rd to 5th March, Lille, France.

    Parker, S.A. , (2002). Second Train Coming Warning Sign Demonstration Projects Research Results Digest. no 51.
    To top.





    More applied psychology for public and transport information

    ContextTitle




    Public infowayfinding signing

    Public infohistory futur train and public transport ticket vending machines

    Public infopublic transport space structure wayfinding signposting

    Public infodesign company logo icon pictogram

    Public infodesign company logo aegon icon pictogram

    Public infosignposting wayfinding signing arrows

    Public infopublic transport space structure wayfinding signposting

    Public infopublic transport space structure wayfinding signposting

    Public infowayfinding signposting signing

    Public info public transporttrain ticket vending machines

    Public info public transportNaming public transport lines for passengers

    Public info public transportpublic transport information on dynamic panels

    Public info public transport ovchipuser experience questionaire research

    Public info road trafficTom Tom infographics car navigation

    Public info road trafficother train accidents level crossings

    Public info road trafficNaming ring roads

    Public info road trafficcar park indicators

    Public info road trafficwrong way driving traffic signs

    Public info waterwaypictogram muster station assemply point IMO ferry signing

    Public infobewegwijzering borden icons pictogrammen verdwalen

    Public infoleren verkeersborden toekomst rijexamen psychologie

    Public info public transportcompany identity en marketing versus noodzakelijke reizigers informatie

    Public info public transportmarketing company identity

    Public info public transport

    Public info public transportdelay announcement departure public transport dynamic indicator

    Public info public transportpublic transport dynamic indicators history future

    Public info public transportpublic transport dynamic indicators history future

    Public info public transporticonen pictogram beelden op verkoopautomaten

    Public info public transportopenbaar vervoer vertrektijden dynamische panelen vertraging verstoring

    Public info public transport ovchipov-chipkaart in-checken out-checken

    Public info public transport ovchipov-chipkaart check-out check-in

    Public info road traffictom tom navigatie auto

    Public info road trafficleren verkeersborden toekomst rijexamen psychologie

    Public info waterwayvaarweg verkeersborden aanleggen watersport



    More applied psychology for other domains:
    ects

      ERMTS hoge snelheidstrein hsl ATB experimenteel interface voor machinist ERMTS high speed train control driver mmi ERMTS hoge snelheidstrein hsl ATB experimenteel interface voor achinist ERMTS hoge snelheidstrein hsl ATB experimenteel interface voor achinist 






    gui



    x Invoer Morsesleutel Toekomst        multidimensionaal graphic   






    icon design



      3-d, perspectief,drie-dimensionaal verkeersbord toekomst parkeerverbod verkeersbord toekomst verboden inhalen verkeersbord toekomst maximum snelheid bepaalde 






    psychologie



    helderheid voor betrouwbaarheid hersenen limgisch systeem en cortex aandacht trekken en aandacht sturen gebruik van de kleuren rood oranje en geel gevoeligheid van het oog voor kleuren humunculus mensmetafoor een mens in de zaadcel 






    public



     NS treinkaart automaat b100 betalen openbaar vervoer NS treinkaart automaat b8060 betalen openbaar vervoer  IMO international maritime organisation muster station sign plattegrond IKEA water vaar verkeersbord maximaal hoogte water vaar verkeersbord maximaal drie dik aanleggen water vaar verkeersbord maximale doorvaart hoogte 3 meter experimenteel vertrektijden bord openbaar vervoer structuur openbare ruimten experimenteel vertrektijden bord openbaar vervoer atb etcs snelheidsbeheersing aandacht trekken water vaar verkeersbord verboden aanleggen water vaar verkeersbord maximale hoogte water vaar verkeersbord verboden 3 dik aanleggen met meer schepen trein vertrektijd perron NS CTA OV openbaar vervoer betalen ov-chipkaart toekomst grafische bestemmingen lijst metro ondergrondse lijn  structuur hoefijzer winkelcentrum 






    toekomst

              






    book

     






    rekenen

    leren rekenen basisschool MAB rekenblokken toekomst onderwijs leren lezen leren rekenen supermarkt leren rekenen basisschool tellen op de vingers aftellen leren rekenen vleksom puntsom rekenonderwijs basisschool tientallig stelsel tellen op de vingers rekenonderwijs basisschool computer diagnostiek remedial teaching graphics for quantitative data next generation 











    Search in humanefficiency.nl




    Contact


    cognitive psychology,  interface design, mmi,  usability, web page design

    +31 (653) 739 750
    Parkstraat 19
    3581 PB Utrecht
    Nederland

    leonardverhoef@gmail.com
    Chamber of commerce number: 39057871, Utrecht.
    To top.