Naming ring roads
Belt, circle, peripheral, ring or round way, which word is the best choice?
TEC, November 2009, pag. 427-428
Dr. Leonard Verhoef,
applied cognitive psychologist.
For designing complex things.
Not a designer.
Leonard Verhoef, theoretical and practical background. From an experimental cognitive psychologist to a designer of simple and complex daily life systems in a technical future.
With click to: CV.
|Ring roads provide an effective structure for efficient traffic flow and the circle is also an effective structure for navigation. Being able to communicate the circularity of the ring road by name and icon on signs, will improve navigation in cities.|
The ring concept
A ring road is a large roundabout. Drivers perfectly understand the concept of a ring. The problems arise when the driver does not understand that the road he is on, is circular.|
Tourists get lost in Amsterdam because they don’t notice that its famous canals are visually straight but physically all are concentric circles. Having this knowledge reduces the chance of getting lost substantially and enables you to navigate without a map.
|Walking along an Amsterdam canal you see a straight canal. However, the Amsterdam canals form concentric rings. In case you don’t notice concentricity you will get lost.|
|The same applies to ring roads. They look like a straight line but they go round in a circle. So it is important that the concept of the ring be flagged up with a word together with some kind of icon that is recognised by the driver to represent the ring.||So important is this concept to understanding, that, to improve navigation, smart designers even impose ringness on structures that physically are ringless.||
Smart design: Making the non-circular physical structure of a furniture shop comprehensible by presenting the chaos as a ring.|
Naming the ring road
Several terms are in use for ring roads.|
Codes like M60 (UK, Manchester) and A10 (Netherlands, Amsterdam) are convenient for computers and bureaucrats.
|Sadly, human eyes and brains are not designed to process numbers and numbers do not enhance orientation because there is no relationship between the code and the concept of the ring.|
Ringness, not indicated, either in words or graphically.
Ringness, not indicated, either in words or graphically.|
The old situation: confusing
|Ringness, indicated graphically. Experimental design.|
|One could establish this relationship by using multiples of ten as a code for ring roads with the zero in the number indicating the road is a ring.||If this were accepted, in practice drivers and strangers would have to learn to associate this code with the fact that the road is a ring road.|
The word periphery (French: Boulevard Périphérique) is closer to representing the circularity of a ring road than a code. Unfortunately it could be interpreted as ring shaped area around a centre. As a result, inexperienced car drivers are liable to follow the sign periphery to get out of town.
This might be understood as:|
To the periphery
This is the periphery.
Closer to ringness is the concept of belt. In the US car drivers understand belt way in this context. French and Italians will be confused. French and Italian have also a word that is only understood in those languages (Italian: Grande Raccorde Anulare). Dutch and Germans might conclude that an Anulare is a road that has been canceled (Dutch: annuleren, German: annulieren). These languages in their turn can confuse foreigners by using the word Gürtel (Vienna) and gordel (Dutch). Gordel is not used on signs in Holland but has the same meaning and would be understood.
|More or less that same applies for loop and orbital.||
Donut for decoration?|
Donut to indicate ring?
|All these words clearly include the concept of ringness but the meaning is not primarily related to traffic and the words are not understood by drivers not belonging to a specific language group. That is a pity because they are the ones that should know they are on a ring road in the first place.|
These language disadvantages apply less for the word ring. This word has no specific meaning. English, German and Dutch speaking drivers will understand the concept. The word is short and does not take much space.
The best choice would be circle, which is understood in most languages. It is used by London underground and Singapore public transport which both having a Circle Line.
|For navigating in cities on rings there are more concepts than only ringness such as: direction (clockwise and anti clockwise), naming and listing exits, you are here and concentricity when there are more ring roads.||Dynamics of traffic and disturbances complicates communication even more. When ringness is not verbalised correctly and not even has an appropriate icon, it is unlikely that these more complex concepts are communicated in a human efficient way.||Downtown Circulator in Pawtucket, best term selected.|
Ring road terms
More applied cognitive psychology for public design:
More applied cognitive psychology for design, other than public
Search in humanefficiency.nl
Fast and errorless human performance using psychology of movement, perception, language, learning and thinking. No manuals, help, explanation, or whatever.
Click leads to: Home page Human Efficiency
Leonard Verhoef, theoretical and practical background. From an experimental coginitive psychologist to a designer of simple and complex daily life systems in a technical future.
Click leads to: CV Leonard Verhoef
+31 (653) 739 750
3581 PB Utrecht
Chamber of commerce number: 39057871, Utrecht.